How two U.S. Navy F-14 Tomcats shot down two Gaddafi’s Su-22 Fitters, 32 years ago today

Aug 19 2013 - 17 Comments

One year ago today, Tony Scott, the famous director of “Top Gun”, chose to commit suicide.

But Aug. 19 was an important date for the Tomcat community, because that day in 1981 US Navy F-14s were employed for the first time in an air to air combat.

For better understanding the facts that led to the downing of two Gaddafi Su-22 Fitter we have to recall the political situation that increased the tension between USA and Libya.

When in 1974 Colonel Gaddafi declared territory of the Libyan Arab Republic the waters below 32° 30’, violating the international laws, the U.S. only response was an ignored official protest.

Even when six years later an American reconnaissance aircraft was attacked in the zone, President Carter ordered the Sixth Fleet to stay away from the area.

When Reagan succeeded to Carter, things changed. In fact he ordered the Navy to conduct the “Freedom of Navigation” (FON) exercises which culminated  in the Open Ocean Missile Exercise (OOMC).

Conducted in August 1981 by USS Forrestal (CV-59) and by USS Nimitz (CVN-68), this training had the aim to show Tripoli that America was serious about its right to project its naval power in international waters.

The rules of engagement (ROE) stated that to protect his assets the on-scene commander could take any necessary action without waiting for a clearance from a higher authority. For fighter pilots this meant “do not fire until fired upon.”

Against the US Navy, Libya could deploy modern and powerful fighters and fighter bombers such as the Soviet-built Su-22 Fitter, MiG-23 Flogger, the Mach 3 interceptor MiG-25 Foxbat and the French-made Mirage F.1 and 5D.

Black Aces 2

In fact, when the exercise began on Aug. 18, 1981, a flight of MiG-25s immediately approached the carrier groups but were intercepted by VF-74 F-4J Phantoms belonging to the USS Forrestal and by VF-41 and VF-84 F-14s launched from USS Nimitz.

The Libyans  were trying to detect the aircraft carriers, and to find them they sent no less than 35 pairs of combat aircraft of each type in their fighter inventory. No shots were fired, but there was a lot of aggressive maneuvering between US Navy and Libyan Air Force fighters.

However a higher state of readiness was placed by the Libyan Air Force in the second day of the exercise.

In fact in the morning of Aug. 19, two VF-41 Black Aces Tomcats, callsigns “Fast Eagle 102” (BuNo. 160403) and “Fast Eagle 107” (BuNo. 160390) stationed in Combat Air Patrol (CAP) off the Libyan coast.

Fast Eagle 102

Towards the end of their patrol, at 07.15 Commander Henry “Hank” Kleemann and its RIO Lieutenant Dave Venlet in “Fast Eagle 102” wit Lieutenant Larry “Music” Muczynski and its RIO Lieutenant James Anderson in “Fast Eagle 107” detected a pair of Su-22 Fitter approaching the two US fighters with their AN/AWG-9 radars.

Two years after these facts, Lt. “Music” Muczynski released the account of the dogfight for Bert kinzey Detail & Scale F-14A & B Tomcat book, so we can read its explanation for better understand how the engagement was won by the Tomcatters:

We arrived down there and went into an orbit pattern on CAP station. The day before, this station had only one intercept, so we were not real happy about being sent down there. In fact we were trying to think of ways to get off of that station and go someplace else. What we had determined was that once we got down to what we call our combat fuel load, we would call for relief on station, go back and hit the tanker, and then go to another station”.  

After forty-five minutes on station “Music” said that “We turned south one more time, and Dave Venlet, Commander Kleemann’s radar officer, picked up a target coming out of the airfield we were watching in Libya. Shortly thereafter, my radar officer, Jim Anderson, picked up the same target. It immediately became obvious that they were coming towards us, because they were heading right at us and climbed to 20,000 feet which was our altitude. They accelerated up to 540 knots. Commander Kleemann was flying lead, and I was flying wingman on his three o’ clock position, about a mile or two out so it was easy to see him. […] As we closed on the Libyans […] it became obvious that they had  good GCI (Ground Control Intercept), in that every time we would take a cut, they would take a cut to neutralize what we had done.”

At this point it became clear that it was impossible for the two Tomcats to gain an initial advantage on the two Fitters and the F-14s went into zone five afterburner (which was the maximum afterburner thrust setting for TF-30 engine) accelerating up to 500 knots.

As recalled by Muczynski “When Commander Kleemann was 1,000 feet in front of them and about 500 feet above them, he rolled his left wing to pass directly above the section so he could get visual ID on them. At that time, the left side of the lead Libyan aircraft lit up with a big flame as the missile motor ignited. I was on that side, so it was very obvious to me with a tremendous orange flash and smoke trail coming off the plane and going under Commander Kleemann’s plane. It then did sort of a banana up toward my plane, but it was also immediately obvious that neither one of us  was going to get hit by the missile, so it didn’t bother either of us.”

Tomcat

Since the Tomcats had been fired at, both Su-22s were immediately declared hostile by the American crews and the two F-14s could now engage the bandits.

“Music” explained that “Commander Kleemann initially had also gone after the leader, but when he saw me closing on him, he reversed his turn back toward the wingman. […] Commander Kleemann got behind the wingman very quickly, but being early in the morning the sun was low on the horizon. The wingman […] happened to fly across the sun as he was making his hard starboard turn. So Commander Kleemann just waited on his shot for the guy to clear the sun. […] As the wingman cleared the sun, Commander Kleemann was about forty degrees off the guy’s tail, at about three-quarters of a mile. He fired an AIM-9L off of station 1A (left glove pylon, shoulder station). The missile pulled lead, then did a ninety degree reversal and hit the aircraft in the tail. […] The aircraft started to roll, the drag chute deployed and the guy immediately ejected. He got a good chute and started down.”

After the wingman it was now the turn of the lead Fitter to face the other Tomcat, this time driven by “Music” himself who recalled “The leader, whom I had gone after, had completed his climbing turn, and was heading straight away north-northwest. He started a slight right hand reversal, but I had obtained a good firing position behind him. I armed up my AIM-9L, and also fired from station 1A. The Sidewinder went right up the guy’s tailpipe and blew off everything from the wing roots rearward in a tremendous fireball. Since I was only one-half mile at the guy’s dead six , the thing that scared me the most was that I would shoot myself down because of the FOD going down the engines. I did a 6 g pull-up, straight into the vertical, and when I cleared the debris pattern, I rolled inverted. I looked down and could see everything from the wings forward spinning on its way down and the plane on fire. After about two turns , I saw the pilot eject from the aircraft, but we did not see him get a good parachute.”

Muczynski ended his account talking about the training and how much it is important in the modern air combat “One thing I would like to say is that I feel that anybody in my squadron could do the same thing that I did. It was simply me being in the right place at the right time with the right results. I am sure that Dave, the Skipper (Commander Kleeman), and Jim Anderson all feel the same way. We are all trained the same, we all do the same flying, we all fly the same aircraft. […] None are any better than the others, and I think the maintenance in VF-41 is Fantastic.”

The two crews returned safely to the Nimitz, while the Libyans began a search and rescue mission to recover their pilots.

One hour later two Foxbats headed at Mach 1.5  towards the carriers, but as the F-14s were launched to intercept them and lit the MiG-25s with their AN/AWG-9 radars, the Libyan fighters turned away and they did not come back.

Anyway, the dogfight between the Tomcats and Fitters marked the first use in combat of the F-14 and it was the first air-to-air combat between swing wings fighters.

And one more thing is remarkable. The time you have spent reading this article is much more than how long the dogfight lasted: no more than 45 seconds from when Libyans shot the missile to the downing of the second Fitter.

David Cenciotti has contributed to this post

 

Enhanced by Zemanta
  • Fishbed

    Su-22 is a fighter-bomber and does not have a radar. The only air-to-air missile of Su-22 is a R-60 (AA-8 APHID) for self defense. So it might have been a suicide attempt of the Libyan pilots to fire the missile or ….:-)

  • Joe Whitty

    I was there there on the round down on watch with a shotgun ready to defend Ronnie Raygun

  • OG_Locc

    I wish they’d have taken that last picture with a horizontal orientation. I want to use it as a wallpaper, but it doesn’t look right with them flying vertically. LOL

  • Dario Leone
    • thebronze

      Thanks Dario!

      I met Kara Hultgreen at the Miramar O-Club a year or two before her untimely death. She was very pretty in the red and white floral dress she was wearing.

      • Dario Leone

        Hi The Bronze, I believe you when you say that Kara was very pretty. I also think that despite her accident she was really happy to finally fly the Tomcat! However I believe that we have got always to remember Capt. Kleeman. He was the first man to bring a US Navy F-14 into in air to air combat!

        • thebronze

          Absolutely!

          Unfortunately, it certainly seems like Lt Hultgreen had many flying deficiencies and shouldn’t have been allowed to fly F-14′s and by doing so, it killed her.

          • Dario Leone

            Yes,

            you are right, unforunately some decisions are only politics and I think that Kara was the result of one of these decisions..

    • thebronze

      I also had occasion to see/touch Capt. Kleeman’s wrecked F-18, while it was sitting at NAS North Island (post crash).

  • Vibayo

    I love this stories. They bring History back to life.

    • Dario Leone

      I think that still today Tomcat and other dismissed aircraft are to beautiful to be forgotten and we can’t forget these planes have also done History.

  • JoeHuttle

    The audio of this incident is on youtube. http://youtu.be/qIUpzNMbfY8 The Transcript is in the description.

  • H Booth

    Curiously, I believe another one of the crew involved in the Sidra incident – Anderson (?) – was killed in a skiing accident in Colorado about two decades ago. Venlet made admiral and commanded NASC a few years back.

  • SPC

    I remember this. We were there in a small Navy Frigate. It was after months of being impotent in the gulf during the hostage crisis under an ineffective Jimmy Carter. Then Ronald Reagan became president and things really started happening around the world. We were steaming with the Nimitz and our captain announced “two of our jets were fired on by Libyan jets. They missed and we didn’t.” Words I will always remember.

  • Brian

    Did anyone else hear “highway to the danger zone” while reading this? The reference to Tony Scott started it, but seeing the callsign ‘Music’ took it to eleven.

  • Christian J Heinbockel

    Calverton, LI, NY where the F-14 was assembled. I was there when the 1st one crashed during testing and I was there when Grumman flew the last 1 out to complete their contract. Amazing to have seen it from beginning to end. Fairchild was also on LI and I saw one of the 1st A-10′s. Come to think of it I also saw an SR-71 in 1968 when it was taking off from either Okinawa or Guam. I was on my way to ‘Nam and we stopped to refuel and all I knew is where we were going, not where we were. Fell in love with that plane in a heartbeat.